Everybody knows how to get out of the recession – it’s easy. You just hang on to your customers and get them to buy more. Oh yes, and you also go out and find a lot more customers. And then you give them all terrific service so they never think of deserting you. And, of course, you do that without letting costs go through the roof.
If it really is that easy, why do so many companies fail to do it? One reason is many of them have no idea who their customers are. For instance, high street retailers have no way of identifying who walks through their doors unless they have some kind of account or loyalty scheme.
Other companies have struggled for years to gain a single view of their customers. Take a bank, for example – it may know you as a current account customer, a pension holder, an insurance policy holder, but each of those items of information will be held in different parts of the organisation. Few such companies have integrated their systems well enough to allow a senior manager to see the total value of that single customer to the business.
Such incomplete knowledge is not limited to the financial services sector and it can have huge knock-on effects in any company. Vital sales opportunities are lost through chasing the wrong prospects, poor strategic decisions are made, and customer service is disjointed and unsatisfactory. When information about customers is held in several different places, something as simple as a change of address can require several phone calls and a lot of internal resource.
The answer to the problem, certainly according to those selling the solutions, is customer relationship management, or CRM. And it is hard to argue with their logic: if you can build a single view of your customers and track your sales opportunities to focus on the best prospects and automate as many parts of the process as possible, then you are more likely to succeed.
“You can’t manage the business on spreadsheets and Outlook folders. You can’t connect it, you can’t report on it, and you need more people to do it that way,” says David Beard, a CRM specialist at Sage UK, which produces a range of CRM packages and systems.
So why isn’t everyone on the CRM bandwagon? One reason is that the concept gained a lot of attention around the turn of the millennium and many companies piled in with big, expensive end-to-end projects that were intended to entirely transform the business. As with so many over-ambitious IT projects, a lot of those projects failed: even now the CRM vendors are still struggling to overcome that bad early track record.
“CRM does still have a bad reputation with some people and the experiences of a few years back linger on,” says Chris Pang, a CRM specialist with the analyst group Gartner. “Now companies are trying not to be too ambitious, and are taking it in more bite-sized pieces. They may now be restricting their projects to sales force automation, a module for campaign management or for customer self-service.”
As a result, projects tend to be less expensive, less complex, quicker to implement and stand a far higher chance of success. “There are still failures in CRM, but they tend to be on a smaller scale,” he says.
Another reason why projects are succeeding is companies have now realised there is more to CRM than software. “In the past, companies left it to the IT department,” Pang says. “We now see more partnership between the business and IT on successful projects.”
When projects do go wrong, he says, it is usually because of a lack of understanding or engagement at board level, or a failure to prepare the people who will be using the system. And companies still underestimate the amount of work involved at the outset to integrate all that disparate information about their customers, which may be scattered across the company on individual databases, spreadsheets, email systems and even on paper.
Sorting it all out is painstaking work, but crucial to the efficacy of the resulting system. “Data quality is still a big issue and few companies have clean customer databases. These are the bugbears that take the shine off CRM projects,” he says.
The goal of any good CRM system should be to integrate everything you know about either an existing customer or a prospect. That will include not only basic details such as name, address, phone numbers and email address, but also their complete sales history. Furthermore it should record every single communication or interaction with the customer, whether by phone, letter, email, or face-to-face meeting.
Everyone who has direct contact with a customer should then have up-to-date facts to hand. For instance, the enthusiastic sales person who is about to call a prospect will appreciate a warning that the same person wrote a letter of complaint the previous week and that no one has yet dealt with the problem.
For Nottingham-based DAS Aerial Communications, the digital switchover of all TVs in the UK by 2012 is a fabulous opportunity.
The company specialises in installing new TV systems and provides a nationwide service to housing associations, nursing homes, football stadiums, airports and private homes.
But taking advantage of the opportunity has required a major re-organisation of the business. As the company’s operations director, Jamie Kurkowski, admits: “We’d got into a bit of a mess and realised we were losing business by not having a co-ordinated approach.”
Interim answers, such as Excel spreadsheets, helped to track customers for a while, but they would not be able to cope with the expected rise in business. “It was a huge opportunity and we needed to maximise the potential,” says Kurkowski. “We wanted to be able to target the large-scale contracts that would be available through the social housing and managing agents.”
In 2008, the company took a serious look at how it planned to track and service the sales opportunities. “We’d also been talking to marketing companies and they’d all asked about what CRM system we were using. And of course we had nothing,” he says. “So we literally Googled ‘CRM’ and stumbled across DMC Software which sells CRM software from Sage. We got a rep to come and see us and we were immediately sold on what it could do for us. It was probably the easiest sale he’d ever made.
They adopted Sage’s SalesLogix system and Kurkowski estimates the company has spent around £180,000 with DMC over the last three years, including consultancy and a lot of tailoring of the system for the company’s needs.
The result is a highly integrated system that can manage a sales opportunity from first enquiries right through to the installation and invoicing. The company sends out regular e-mail blasts and newsletters and advertises in specialist magazines such as Housing Matters. The system allows it to track the effectiveness of each of these activities and also lets the senior management view the sales pipeline at any time.
The return on investment has been dramatic. In 2007, DAS turnover was less than £2m. By 2009, it had grown to £8m, and the win rate for each sales opportunity is now at 60%, compared with around 35% three years ago.
The next step is to provide BlackBerry devices to all staff in the field, so that they can immediately update the CRM system after every customer visit. This will cut out a lot of tedious data entry work at head office, as well as speeding up the current paper-based process.
With the information in one place, customer service or call centre workers are better able to deal with customer enquiries on the spot, rather than passing them to another department or promising to call back with an answer.
The benefits don’t stop there. You can analyse which customers buy what and who are the most and least profitable. You can track the success of marketing campaigns, and maximise their effectiveness by targeting them at those people who are most likely to buy.
By collecting website enquiries, responses to advertisements and data from bought-in databases, you can also harness the CRM system to recruit new customers and then track the pipeline of sales opportunities from initial interest right through to sale and after-sales service. You can even send out invoices automatically if the CRM is integrated with the accounts system.
And, to cap it all, senior management no longer have to believe the optimistic forecasts of their sales force; now they can see for themselves what is happening – which sales people are performing, which customers are buying, and which marketing vehicles are proving the most effective. That kind of knowledge is a strategic goldmine when it comes to outperforming your rivals in a recovering but still sluggish market.
But hang on a minute. If it all sounds a bit too good to be true, for many companies, that’s exactly how it turns out. Realising all those theoretical benefits relies on the diligent, accurate and consistent collection of data at all stages of the process and that seems to be the part where many firms struggle.
Technology can help – for instance, many CRM systems will integrate with corporate email, so that every email exchange will be visible from the CRM system. Similarly, computer-telephone integration will help call centre workers record phone transactions and tie them to the customer record.
Sales people can often pose the biggest challenge – they may be part of a team but more often that not they are paid according to their own individual revenue targets. Where’s the incentive for them to share what they know about customers with their colleagues – indeed the whole company – via the CRM system if it means that someone else might get the credit for ‘your’ sale?
According to Mike Ramsay, head of DMC Software in Peterborough, which specialises in CRM, the trick is to persuade them of the advantages. “Sales people often fear that they are being watched, so you have to sell it to them, and persuade them they’ll make a lot more money if they use the system properly,” he says. “And you need to build it into their KPIs so part of the bonuses is based on their use of the system.”
However, Steve Gleed, a partner at PWC, warns that even such relatively sophisticated incentives may not work. “There has been
a questionable use of carrot and stick. You get sales people entering the data the day before the order is due, because they can’t get their commission until it’s in the system. It misses the fundamental value of CRM,” he says. “The behavioural change piece is the hardest to get right. Sales people by definition don’t like to be controlled.”
He adds that when CRM is done well, the information can be used by sales management to provide real support to their sales teams, balancing their workload, and helping them focus on their best prospects. “That way, the sales people see the value in sharing their opportunity information because they knows it’s ultimately of value to them,” he says.
It is clear then that while technology can provide the tools to do the job, getting CRM to work is more about getting processes properly organised and people on board. Indeed the Gartner Group recommends eight key building blocks for successful CRM which include vision, strategy, organisational change, clean data, proper metrics – and technology. Without these factors, as companies found in the first wave of CRM projects, the technology is bound to fail.
That view is supported by recent research by the Aberdeen Group, which examined nearly 400 companies around the world to see how well they were coping with the recession and if they were hanging on to their customers.
The resulting report “Creating a 360o view of the Customer” graded each of the companies according to how well it had retained customers during difficult economic times. As the authors say, personalised customer service can become an effective means of creating differentiation, especially where products have become commoditised.
The best performing 20% of companies surveyed managed an impressive 91% customer retention and 88% customer satisfaction and yet spent only 6% of their time searching for customer information and managed to achieve a 6% increase in net client value during the recession.
And CRM technology certainly seems to be helping them achieve their numbers. Of those best-performing firms, 80% ensured that customer-facing staff could see the full customer history and 72% monitored customer satisfaction on a regular basis. Just over half of them (52%) had a technology-based common view of the customer.
Those companies managed to increase customer value when times were tough, so there must be a lesson in there for everyone. And when times get easier, being able to keep and win customers will be even more important.
Deltalight imports upmarket light fittings from Belgium which it sells mainly to architects and building developers across the UK. Based in Surrey, it has a London showroom and employs 26 people.
Up to three years ago, the company used what managing director Adrian Cutting describes as a “Heath Robinson database we built ourselves” to manage customer details. “It grew and grew until it became unworkable,” he recalls.
Since the company was already using finance software from Sage, it decided to adopt the Sage 1000 package which provided both accounts and CRM in one. The package was heavily tailored to meet their needs, which on reflection he thinks was “possibly not the best way forward” because it made the system somewhat unstable.
Nevertheless it introduced Deltalight to CRM, and working with Sage partner Pinnacle Computing Solutions, the company has now upgraded to a new and rather less tailored version of the system. “The bugs have been ironed out and it’s doing an exceptional job,” he says. “The best thing from the start would have been to take it out of the box, play with it for a while and then tailor it once we knew what we really needed.”
As with most CRM implementations, users needed to be convinced initially. “Everyone was reluctant to change the way they worked at first. Only now are they beginning to realise that the information they have to input actually means something. But once they sees the results, and it starts to benefit their pockets, they are happy to use it,” says Cutting.
Deltalight uses the system primarily to manage the sales process, from scheduling appointments with customers through to closing sales. “It’s a powerful sales tracker,” he says. “And once we win the contract it flows straight through to the Sage finance system, spits out an invoice and allocates the job to an engineer so he gets his commission. It pretty much does it all.”
The system also allows them to track how well they do against their competition and to analyse why they are winning or losing against them.
Cutting is convinced the system has helped Deltalight ride the recession. While his industry saw a 35% downturn, Deltalight dropped by just 12%. “We beat our revised budget and we think that was because of the efficiency this system has given us,” he says.